AnswerPlume

AI search answered 12 "best [product]" shopping questions. The brands' own sites got 0 of 60 citations (Nov 4, 2026)

Method. On Wed Nov 4, 2026, about 8:30 AM PT, we ran 12 consumer "best [product] 2026" questions (mattress, running shoes, protein powder, robot vacuum, carry-on, electric toothbrush, puppy food, face sunscreen, office chair, meal kits, blue-light glasses, weighted blanket) through the same AI web-search answer tool used for POST-001. Each answer came with 5 source links. We labeled every cited domain: brand (makes the product), retailer, publisher (media), independent review/testing site, nonprofit, or professional (e.g., a vet chain). One run per query, one engine, one location. It's a snapshot. Raw data: runs-2026-11-04-dtc.csv.

Findings (counts from the CSV) - 0 of 60 citations went to a brand's own site. Not one, even though every answer named brands (Helix, ASICS, Transparent Labs, Roborock, Travelpro, Oral-B, Hill's, La Roche-Posay, Steelcase, HelloFresh, Gunnar, Silk & Snow came first). - Publishers took 37 of 60 (62%), independent review/testing sites took 16 (27%), and retailers 3 (5%: Chewy, Fleet Feet, BTOD). Nonprofits had 3 and professional sites had 1. - Two domains took 10 of 60: forbes.com (5) and nytimes.com/Wirecutter (5). Good Housekeeping had 4. Wired and Consumer Reports had 3 each. We counted 40 different domains. - 23 of 60 cited page titles say "test," "tested" or "testing" (one of those is the site name The Run Testers), and 47 of 60 have "2026" in the title. - Compare to POST-001 (Nov 3, B2B software): there, vendor-owned pages got 32 of 50 B2B citations (64%). In consumer products, the brand's blog didn't show up at all. The roundup it lands in counts.

What a mid-market DTC brand can do (no tricks): find out which 5–10 roundups the engines cite for your category (that's this CSV, per category), and make sure your product is in them on its merits. Send review units to the testers, keep specs and prices current on the pages that list you, and fix any outdated facts. Your own site still matters for the facts those writers copy (specs, sizes, warranty, price). Put them in a plain table with a date.

Limits: one engine, one run, 12 queries, our own domain labels. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews weren't tested. They need paid API access or sign-ins. Not a ranking study.

Raw data

Download CSV

querycited_domaindomain_typefirst_brand_recommended
best mattress for back pain 2026ncoa.orgnonprofitHelix Midnight Luxe
aarp.orgpublisher
sleepfoundation.orgindependent
wired.compublisher
forbes.compublisher
best running shoes for beginners 2026rtings.comindependentASICS Novablast 6
theruntesters.comindependent
runnersworld.compublisher
runnersworld.compublisher
fleetfeet.comretailer
best protein powder for women 2026aarp.orgpublisherTransparent Labs
fortune.compublisher
forbes.compublisher
thegoodtrade.comindependent
goodhousekeeping.compublisher
best robot vacuum for pet hair 2026tomsguide.compublisherRoborock Saros 20
vacuumwars.comindependent
nymag.compublisher
consumerreports.orgindependent
forbes.compublisher
best carry-on luggage 2026nytimes.compublisherTravelpro Platinum Elite
outdoorgearlab.comindependent
beyondbaggage.comindependent
theguardian.compublisher
wired.compublisher
best electric toothbrush 2026nytimes.compublisherOral-B Pro 1000
goodhousekeeping.compublisher
wired.compublisher
techradar.compublisher
consumerreports.orgindependent
best dog food for puppies 2026chewy.comretailerHill's Science Diet Puppy
vcahospitals.comprofessional
aafco.orgnonprofit
petmd.compublisher
dogfoodadvisor.comindependent
best sunscreen for face 2026nytimes.compublisherLa Roche-Posay Anthelios
usnews.compublisher
theguardian.compublisher
prevention.compublisher
independent.co.ukpublisher
best office chair for back pain 2026spineandseat.comindependentSteelcase Leap V2
btod.comretailer
theofficejournal.comindependent
forbes.compublisher
cnn.compublisher
best meal kit delivery service 2026foodnetwork.compublisherHelloFresh
nytimes.compublisher
businessinsider.compublisher
seriouseats.compublisher
goodhousekeeping.compublisher
best blue light glasses brand 2026optimizeyourbiology.comindependentGunnar
optimizeyourbiology.comindependent
forbes.compublisher
health.compublisher
humanwindow.comindependent
best weighted blanket 2026ncoa.orgnonprofitSilk & Snow
goodhousekeeping.compublisher
nytimes.compublisher
today.compublisher
consumerreports.orgindependent