AnswerPlume

Who AI search cites for "best [service] [city]" — local services vs software vs shopping (Nov 5, 2026)

Method. On Thu Nov 5, 2026, about 8:10 AM PT, we ran 12 mid-market local and professional-service questions ("best HVAC company Las Vegas," "best plumber Austin," "best divorce attorney Chicago," "best orthodontist Denver," "best commercial cleaning NYC," "best MSP for small business," "best bookkeeping for contractors," "best wedding photographer Miami," "best personal injury lawyer Phoenix," "best roofing company Dallas," "best veterinary clinic Seattle," "best IT support for dental offices" — each with 2026) through the same AI web-search answer tool used for POST-001 and POST-002. Each answer came with 5 source links. We labeled every cited domain: brand (the service business itself), directory (Angi, WeddingWire, The Knot and similar), publisher, aggregator (list/roundup sites), nonprofit, or other. One run per query, one engine, one location. Snapshot only. Raw data: runs-2026-11-05-local-services.csv.

Findings (counts from the CSV) - 17 of 60 citations (28%) went to a brand's own site. Nine of the twelve questions had at least one brand page in the five sources. - Aggregators took 26 of 60 (43%) — the largest share. Directories had 6 (10%), publishers 7 (12%), other 3, nonprofit 1 (Consumers' Checkbook for Seattle vets). - exa.ai appeared 4 times and expertise.com 3 times. WeddingWire and The Knot each took 2 slots on the Miami photographer question. We counted 50 different domains across 60 slots. - Being named first is not the same as being cited. Eleven answers named a first pick (Desert West, Blue Dragon Plumbing, Beermann LLP and others); several of those brands never appeared in the five source links. - Compare to prior posts: POST-001 (Nov 3, B2B software) had vendor-owned pages on 32 of 50 B2B citations (64%). POST-002 (Nov 4, consumer DTC) had 0 of 60 brand sites. Local services sit in the middle: brand sites show up, but list and directory pages still own the plurality.

What a mid-market service business can do (no tricks): treat the aggregator and directory pages this engine already cites (Expertise, Angi, WeddingWire/The Knot, BestInHood, Roofing Scout, G2 for MSPs) as the pages that must name you accurately — reviews, license, service area, hours. Keep your own site current with a dated service list, cities served, and credentials; when brand pages got cited here, they were usually practice or company home pages, not blog posts. One bookkeeping query returned software roundups (QuickBooks first), not local bookkeepers — category wording matters.

Limits: one engine, one run, 12 queries, our own domain labels. ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews weren't tested. Not a ranking study.

Raw data

Download CSV

querycited_domaindomain_typefirst_brand_recommended
best HVAC company Las Vegas 2026exa.aiaggregatorDesert West
serviceagent.aiaggregator
rocketairconditioning.combrand
thecoolingco.combrand
angi.comdirectory
best plumber Austin 2026siftpros.comaggregatorBlue Dragon Plumbing
rootermanofaustin.combrand
ironcladtexas.combrand
theaustinnewsletter.compublisher
statesman.compublisher
best divorce attorney Chicago 2026chicagodivorce.orgaggregatorBeermann LLP
attorneyinputs.comaggregator
asfamlaw.combrand
expertise.comaggregator
bestlawfirms.comaggregator
best orthodontist Denver 2026speaksorthodontics.combrandSpeaks Orthodontics
exa.aiaggregator
trommeterortho.combrand
trustanalytica.orgaggregator
doctor.webmd.comaggregator
best commercial cleaning NYC 2026bestinhood.comaggregatorGermSmart Commercial Cleaning
onpattison.compublisher
anvilclean.combrand
blog.facilitybot.coother
newyorkcitytoprated.comaggregator
best MSP for small business 2026g2.comaggregatorElectric
briskly.toolsaggregator
beefedupit.combrand
lockbaud.combrand
gartsolutions.combrand
best bookkeeping for contractors 2026myofficeops.comotherQuickBooks Online Plus
augmentedtrades.comother
contractortoolstack.comaggregator
planyard.combrand
forbes.compublisher
best wedding photographer Miami 2026weddingwire.comdirectoryBells & Whistles Photography
theknot.comdirectory
weddingwire.comdirectory
theknot.comdirectory
weddingrule.comaggregator
best personal injury lawyer Phoenix 2026expertise.comaggregatorHirsch & Lyon
sargonlawgroup.combrand
attorneystimes.comaggregator
lawfirmsquare.comaggregator
thephoenixreview.compublisher
best roofing company Dallas 2026roofingscout.comaggregatorArrington Roofing
homematchup.comaggregator
forbes.compublisher
exa.aiaggregator
expertise.comaggregator
best veterinary clinic Seattle 2026bestinhood.comaggregatorNorth Seattle Veterinary Clinic
rankings.newsweek.compublisher
checkbook.orgnonprofit
exa.aiaggregator
vetsinseattle.comdirectory
best IT support for dental offices 2026medixdental.combrandDarkhorse Tech
cybercore.dentalbrand
pact-one.combrand
theuptimereport.comaggregator
pact-one.combrand